Sunlit ivory stucco entry with a gray-green door, terracotta roof tiles, exposed-aggregate walk, and flowering sage beneath a branching tree.

Downtown Redlands Parking: Why Try the Stuart Avenue Garage?

"You think they're going to go two blocks away and come across?" Councilmember Paul Barich asked at the September 21 City Council meeting, as the Redlands Daily Facts reported. "Not a chance." He was talking about a proposed lot between Seventh and Ninth streets, and the council dropped it.

His point about walking distance shows up in the city's own numbers. It also explains a strange fact about downtown Redlands. The spaces drivers fight over and the spaces that sit empty are close to each other. The empty ones are on the far side of the train tracks, or in lots most drivers never think to try. Nearly every parking decision made downtown this year has gone after that unused supply instead of building more.

The Garage That Sat Mostly Empty at the Busiest Hour

In 2023, Walker Consultants finished a downtown parking study for the city. It found that demand peaked on a Thursday at 1 p.m. At that hour, 48% of the counted spaces downtown were in use. That works out to about 1,875 cars and more than 2,052 open spaces.

The average hides where the pressure actually is. Here is how the city's public lots looked at that same peak hour:

Public facility Spaces Occupied at Thursday 1 p.m. peak
Citrus Avenue structure 194 99%
Ed Hales Park lot 61 97%
City Hall surface lot 25 88%
Orange Street lot 53 74%
Block 22 56 46%
Stuart Avenue structure 385 16%

The biggest public garage downtown was the emptiest. The Stuart Avenue structure has more spaces than the Citrus Avenue structure and Ed Hales combined. At peak, it had about 324 open spaces, while the Citrus Avenue garage had two. The study placed the crunch on and around State Street and inside the Citrus Avenue garage. It found plenty of open space in outlying on-street areas and in private lots.

Those counts come from a study published in 2023, so treat them as a pattern, not a live reading. Still, the pattern explains why circling State Street feels hopeless while a few hundred spaces sit open nearby. The city's parking map lists the Stuart structure at 101 W. Stuart Ave. with 385 spaces and labels it "Open." The Orange Street and Ed Hales lots are marked "3 Hour." The study also describes the public structures as unrestricted.

The Public Market Just Made the Same Bet

On October 5, Community Forward Redlands reported that Redlands Public Market now rents 53 spaces on the east side of the former LOOK Cinemas property for free customer parking. Owner Jerry Tessier said that when those spaces fill up, customers can use free 90-minute street parking or the city's Stuart Avenue structure. He said the garage is less than a two-minute walk from the market across the train tracks.

The LOOK lot is a good choice. In the 2023 study, the LOOK Theater lot had 260 spaces and was 17% occupied at peak. The study also recommended opening underused private lots to the public through leases, purchases or shared-use agreements, and it named the LOOK Theater lot as a candidate. Centennial Plaza, Redlands Plaza, Wells Fargo, First Congregational and The Door were on the same list. A private business has now done what the study suggested, for one of the lots it named.

Two details matter on your next visit. The rest of the former theater lot is paid parking, so the free spaces are the 53 on the east side. And if you're only picking up a to-go order, the green curb on Third Street in front of the market allows up to 10 minutes.

Why the Seventh Street Lot Never Got Built

The shelved lot makes more sense against those numbers. It would have added 140 free spaces on about two acres between Seventh and Ninth streets, north of Redlands Boulevard. The land belongs to the San Bernardino County Transportation Authority. Construction would have cost nearly $650,000, and the city had already spent close to $104,000 on design before the council stopped it. City Manager Charles Duggan called the project largely "unfunded." A city report said leasing the land would have required $750,000 in capital investment from the city.

The funding problem decided the vote. The distance argument at the meeting, though, matches what the study found. Drivers fill the spaces closest to State and Orange streets and leave the farther ones empty. A 140-space lot two blocks out would likely have ended up much like the Stuart garage, with plenty of room that few people use. Tessier's directions to the Stuart garage lead with the walk, under two minutes from the market.

The Mall Lot Is Borrowed Time

A lot of downtown parking currently sits on the former Redlands Mall site, and that supply is temporary. The 2023 study left the mall lot out of its supply count. Its reasoning was that the approved project for the site would eventually remove the lot as public parking, though cars parked there were still counted as demand.

On April 7, 2026, the council unanimously approved a license with the site's owner, Town Square Development Group. The deal keeps about 520 mall-lot spaces open to the public during the early phases of demolition and redevelopment. The city pays about $29,084 a month and handles maintenance, security, cleaning and insurance. The license runs through April 2029. Either side can end it early, and the developer can close parts of the lot with 10 days' notice, paying the city $2 per space per day for the lost spaces.

On the site itself, Community Forward Redlands' August 27 update reported that asbestos abatement and structural work were underway inside the remaining mall building to prepare for demolition. City officials gave no firm teardown timeline. The city's Major Projects List, updated October 14, 2026, still shows the earlier State Street Village approval, with up to 700 units.

So the 520 spaces many drivers count on are rented, and sections can close with 10 days' notice. The Stuart garage is city-owned, and the study counted roughly 324 empty spaces there at peak. When parts of the mall lot close, the Stuart garage is the obvious place for those cars to go.

Two other ideas from the past few years haven't produced anything yet. In February 2024, the council voted to explore a downtown shuttle. The estimate was $482,000 a year for three five-passenger, golf-cart-style vehicles running five days a week. Earlier, in its review of the Walker report, the Traffic and Parking Commission did not support a paid-parking program, according to Community Forward Redlands. Neither one is running downtown today. The plan for now is the same as this fall's changes: use the parking that already exists.

Where to Park on a Downtown Night, in Order

Put together, the research gives a simple order of places to try, starting with the most reliable:

  1. Stuart Avenue structure, 101 W. Stuart Ave. It's the largest public facility downtown, with 385 spaces, and it was the emptiest at the study's peak hour. It's the most dependable choice for dinner on State Street or an evening at the Public Market.
  2. The east side of the former LOOK Cinemas lot, if you're going to Redlands Public Market. Those 53 spaces are free for market customers. The rest of that lot is paid.
  3. On-street parking on the side streets. The study found that about 70% of downtown street spaces had posted limits, most often two hours. Side streets and some edges of downtown had no limits, and the open street spaces were mostly north of Redlands Boulevard, west of Orange Street and south of Olive Street. Posted signs are the final word.
  4. The Third Street green curb, for a quick Public Market pickup of 10 minutes or less.
  5. Citrus Avenue and Ed Hales last. They were 99% and 97% full at the study's peak, so a driver who starts there may spend the evening circling.

Timing matters too. In its March 2024 notice, the City of Redlands said posted time limits downtown are enforced Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., and not on weekends or holidays. If you're riding Arrow, Metrolink says parking is free for its passengers at Redlands–Downtown, 351 Orange Street, and at Redlands–University, 1100 East Park Avenue.

If you've lived near downtown for years, you've seen these parking changes happen one lot at a time, and they shape how easy downtown is to use every day. If you're weighing what changes like this could mean for your own home, Terri Barrett has followed Redlands closely for nearly 30 years and is glad to talk it through. Schedule a Free Consultation whenever you're ready.

Work With Terri

I am known for being an excellent communicator and a trusted advisor, always ensuring my clients feel informed, supported, and genuinely cared for throughout the entire process. For me, real estate isn’t just about transactions—it’s about relationships.

Follow Me on Instagram